Optimizing the Relationship with the Executive Director
Building a strong partnership between the Board and Executive Director is critical for nonprofit effectiveness, shaping organizational culture and success.
Building a Healthy Employment Relationship
Clear Roles & Boundaries
Define and respect the division: Board governs (strategy, policy, evaluation), ED manages (operations, staff, implementation). Avoid board micromanagement and ensure the ED respects governance and informs the board. A formal Delegation of Authority policy clarifies who decides what, setting limits (e.g., spending thresholds) and reserving key matters for the board.
Open Communication
Maintain ongoing dialogue, primarily between the Chair and ED (e.g., regular check-ins), to prevent surprises. The ED should share good and bad news transparently with the full board (via reports, updates). Candor is vital; address concerns directly.
Unified Direction
Present a united front on strategy. Handle internal disagreements privately within the board, not publicly or with staff. The ED should support board decisions. Avoid undermining each other's authority.
Support & Advice vs. Interference
Act as coaches or advisors; offer expertise and a sounding board. Don't give direct orders to staff or manage operations. Remember: "Noses in, fingers out" – stay informed but don't operate.
No Triangulation
Board requests to staff generally go through the ED. Individual board members should not give directives to staff, preserving the chain of command. Loop the ED into official communications.
Respect & Appreciation
Acknowledge the demands of the ED role and celebrate successes. The ED should value the board's volunteer contributions. Foster mutual professional respect, even during critique.
Handling Conflict
Address performance issues or board overreach promptly and professionally, usually via Chair-ED discussions. Early, frank conversation can prevent crises.
A healthy partnership means the board supports the ED, and the ED keeps the board informed and confident in their leadership, boosting overall organizational impact. Aim for a "same team" mentality.
Recruitment & Selection
Succession Planning
Ideally, have emergency and long-term succession plans ready before a vacancy occurs to ensure a smooth, non-crisis recruitment.
Form a Search Committee
Appoint a committee (often including the Chair) to lead the search. Consider including key external stakeholders for broader input.
Define Position & Qualifications
Update the job description based on current organizational needs. Identify essential skills, experience, and cultural fit required for the next leader.
Decide Search Strategy
Choose between an internal search, using networks/job boards, or hiring an executive search firm (cost vs. reach/expertise). Ensure broad outreach for diversity. Perform due diligence even with internal candidates.
Screening & Interviewing
The committee screens applicants, conducts initial interviews, and presents finalists. The full board typically meets the final 2-3 candidates. Use behavioral questions, assess soft skills, and rigorously check references and background.
Decision & Offer
The full board approves the final candidate based on the committee's recommendation after candid discussion (in executive session). Make a competitive offer (salary, benefits) formalized in an employment agreement reviewed by legal counsel.
Onboarding the New ED
Implement a structured onboarding plan. Facilitate introductions to key stakeholders. Clarify first-year expectations. Manage any overlap with the previous ED carefully to empower the new leader.
Communicate the Transition
Announce the new hire positively to all stakeholders. Publicly thank the outgoing ED (if appropriate).
ED recruitment requires rigor similar to financial oversight. Mistakes are costly. The goal is a competent leader aligned with the mission who can partner effectively with the board.
Compensation
Competitive & Fair Pay
Research comparable nonprofits (size, budget, region) using surveys or public data (e.g., Form 990s/T3010s) to set a salary that attracts and retains talent without being excessive. In the US, follow IRS Intermediate Sanctions guidelines (use data, independent approval, documentation) to avoid penalties. In Canada, ensure reasonableness for CRA compliance.
Compensation Structure
Determine the mix of salary, benefits (health, retirement), and potential performance-based incentives (rare in nonprofits, but possible if metrics are clear). Document all components.
Transparency & Approval
The full board (or designated committee with board ratification) approves the ED's compensation package without the ED present. Record the decision in minutes.
Regular Reviews
Review compensation annually, usually alongside the performance evaluation. Adjust based on performance, organizational growth, budget constraints, and updated market data.
Benefits & Perks
Ensure alignment with overall staff benefits policies for fairness and morale. Document and justify any executive-specific perks (e.g., professional development allowance).
Legal Compliance
Adhere to IRS/CRA rules, accurately report compensation (Form 990/T3010), and ensure compliance with employment laws regarding ED classification (e.g., exempt status).
Communication with ED
Clearly explain the compensation philosophy, process, and link to performance. Avoid surprises.
Balance stewardship of funds with the need for strong leadership. Paying fairly enables the mission. Document the process and be prepared to justify the compensation based on data and due diligence.
Oversight
Reporting & Accountability
Receive and review regular ED reports on activities, finances, and strategic progress. Verify performance against plans and ask clarifying questions. Expect explanations and corrective actions for deviations.
Financial Oversight
Regularly review financial statements (budget vs. actual, cash flow). Ensure prudent financial management within the approved budget, proper internal controls, and follow-up on audit findings. The ED must alert the board to significant financial issues.
Policy Compliance
Monitor the ED's implementation of board-approved policies (HR, ethics, safety, legal). Verify compliance through ED reports and occasional checks (e.g., timely tax filings like Form 990/T3010).
Risk Oversight
Ensure the ED identifies and manages key organizational risks (operational, financial, reputational). Review risk assessments, insurance adequacy, emergency plans, and cybersecurity measures. Ask probing questions about risk mitigation.
Ethical Oversight
Ensure the ED fosters an ethical culture and operates with integrity. Establish channels (like whistleblower policies) for reporting concerns directly to the board, and investigate any allegations promptly.
Effective oversight involves verification and accountability through regular reporting and dialogue. It helps identify issues early, supports the ED in course correction, and gives the board confidence in the organization's management. No Micro-Oversight: Focus on high-level monitoring and outcomes, not daily operational details. Avoid bypassing the ED to deal directly with other staff on management issues.
Evaluation
Agree on Goals & Criteria
Set clear, measurable performance goals and leadership expectations collaboratively at the beginning of the evaluation period. Base criteria on the job description and strategic priorities.
Gather Input
Collect performance data through the ED's self-assessment, input from all board members (e.g., via survey), and potentially carefully gathered stakeholder feedback. Focus on agreed-upon goals and competencies.
Executive Session Discussion
The board discusses the ED's performance candidly (without the ED present), consolidating feedback professionally and factually.
Feedback Meeting
The Chair (± others) delivers the evaluation constructively. Acknowledge strengths and successes first, then discuss areas for development with specific examples. Avoid surprises; address major concerns as they arise during the year, not just at the review. Reset goals for the upcoming year.
Written Record
Document the evaluation summary, including achievements, areas for improvement, and future goals. Provide a copy to the ED and keep one in confidential files.
Link to Compensation & Development
Use the evaluation results to inform decisions about salary adjustments or bonuses. Identify and support the ED's professional development needs.
Board Self-Reflection
Consider how the board's actions may have supported or hindered the ED's performance. Use this insight to improve board effectiveness and the partnership.
Consistent evaluation fulfills the board's supervisory duty, reinforces accountability, motivates the ED, and provides valuable feedback for growth. Even if potentially awkward, it's essential for strong leadership and governance.
Executive Director Succession Planning & Delegation of Authority
Succession Planning
Proactive ED succession planning is vital for leadership continuity and organizational stability:
- Emergency Succession Plan: Have a documented plan designating an Acting ED and outlining key steps (notifications, signing authority) if the ED departs suddenly. Review annually.
- Planned Succession Strategy: Develop a timeline and process for anticipated departures (e.g., retirement). Consider grooming internal candidates, define the outgoing ED's transition role, establish a search/transition committee, and plan stakeholder communications.
- Interim Leadership: Consider hiring an experienced Interim ED to provide stability during extended searches or organizational transitions. Clarify if an internal interim is eligible for the permanent role.
- Develop Internal Talent: Encourage the ED to build leadership capacity within the staff. Cross-train key staff on essential functions. Familiarize potential internal successors with the board.
- Document Key Information: Ensure critical organizational knowledge (key relationships, processes, passwords) is documented and accessible beyond the ED.
- Manage the Transition: When a new ED starts, focus on effective onboarding. Manage the outgoing ED's departure respectfully, clearly defining any future relationship (e.g., advisor, board member) to avoid undermining the new leader. Consider a cooling-off period before an outgoing ED joins the board.
Integrate succession planning into regular strategic discussions. Having plans normalizes the topic and protects the mission's longevity, signaling organizational maturity and resilience.
Delegation of Authority
A formal Delegation of Authority (DOA) policy clarifies decision-making boundaries between the board and the ED, preventing confusion and micromanagement:
- Board-Reserved Decisions: The policy explicitly lists major decisions requiring board approval (e.g., strategy, budget, ED hire/fire, large contracts/expenditures above a threshold, debt, mergers, dissolution).
- Executive Director Authority: Delegates day-to-day management and operational decisions to the ED (e.g., staffing below ED level, implementing approved plans/budgets, contracts within limits). If not reserved by the board, the ED generally has authority.
- Specific Role Authorities: May detail spending or signing authority limits for the ED, CFO, or other key staff roles.
- Emergency Powers: May allow the ED (in consultation with the Chair) to act unilaterally in urgent situations, with prompt reporting to the board afterward.
- Regular Review: Periodically review and update the DOA policy to ensure it remains appropriate for the organization's size and complexity.
The DOA empowers the ED to manage efficiently while maintaining board control over critical matters. It enhances clarity, accountability, and good governance. While authority is delegated, the ED should still keep the board informed of significant actions taken under this authority.
Nonprofit Board Governance Guide
This comprehensive guide breaks down nonprofit governance into eight essential sections.
Whether you're new to board service or a seasoned leader, you'll find valuable insights.
Ditch the Email Chaos. Manage Your Nonprofit Board the Smart Way.
Tired of scattered documents, endless email threads, and tracking down votes? Quorum brings everything your board needs into one secure, affordable platform.
Lost Files?
Centralized dashboard with secure AWS S3 document storage keeps everything organized.
Meeting Mayhem?
Integrated agendas, notes and decision logging with rich text editing.
Voting Hassles?
Secure online voting with anonymous options, receipts and easy tracking.
Just $20/Board/Month with unlimited members included. No per-user fees.